Shudder to Think played their first shows in 12 years & debuted a new song (setlist, video)

Shudder to Think just played their first shows since 2013, two back-to-back afternoon sets at LA’s Permanent Records in their Roadhouse venue. According to setlist.fm, but the 2 PM and 4 PM sets featured the same 13-song setlist which featured lots of “90s classics and was heavy on Pony Express Record, (“X-French Tee Shirt,” “Gang of $,” “Earthquakes Come Home” and more), plus “Lies Stay in the Sky” “Red House,” and more. Excitingly both songs ended with “Day Ditty” and then new song “Playback.”

Is there more coming? A new song certainly bodes well. Stay tuned. Check out the setlist and some fan shot video from the Permanent Records Roadhouse setlist below.

SETLIST: Shudder to Think @ Permanent Records Roadhouse 3/25/2025
Hit Liquor
Gang of $
Red House
Love Catastrophe
9 Fingers on You
Kissi Penny
Lies About the Sky
So Into You (Atlanta Rhythm Section cover)
Earthquakes Come Home
Pebbles
X-French Tee Shirt

Encore:
Day Ditty
Playback